20 Printable Mystery Games for 2026
Are you ready to host a fun and thrilling mystery party? These 20 printable mystery games are perfect for any gathering.
Each game comes with interesting plots, unique settings, and clear instructions. They make your event exciting and easy to organize.
From tropical resorts to 1980s high school proms, these games provide hours of entertainment and mystery-solving fun.
1. Way Out West
Way Out West is a Wild West-themed game set in Cactus Gulch in 1884.
Players meet sheriffs, cowboys, and saloon girls while solving a murder and other hidden plots.
It is suitable for 10 to 24 players and recommended for ages 12 and up. The host organizes the game for smooth play.
2. Jazz Age Jeopardy
Set in a 1920s jazz club, Jazz Age Jeopardy has players dress in period clothes.
Guests solve a murder while navigating personal goals and secrets. The game supports large groups and is printable.
It’s ideal for parties where everyone can enjoy teamwork and mystery-solving in a fun atmosphere.
3. Murder, She Wrote
Fans of the TV show “Murder, She Wrote” can follow an episode while solving a mystery.
Players need a Peacock Premium subscription to watch the show. The number of participants is flexible.
This game is perfect for people who enjoy TV-based mysteries and want an interactive experience.
4. Case of the Unfortunate Acrobat
This circus-themed game is set in 1885, revolving around the death of a trapeze artist.
Players receive letters, witness statements, and other clues to solve the mystery. It is printable and fits various group sizes.
The circus setting makes the game unique and fun for anyone who loves a dramatic story.
5. Murder at Mardi Gras
Players solve the murder of Pierre DuPre during a Mardi Gras celebration.
The game includes invitations, character sheets, and clues. It is suitable for multiple players and available on Amazon.
This game brings the colorful Mardi Gras atmosphere to your mystery party.
6. Finders Seekers Mysteries
Finders Seekers Mysteries is a subscription box delivering a new mystery each month.
Each box features a city or cultural theme with puzzles, codes, and cryptic messages. It takes 1.5 to 3 hours to complete.
It works for 1 to 4 players, ideal for solo or small groups. Subscriptions start at $30 per month.
7. Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle
This game combines a mystery with a jigsaw puzzle challenge.
Players can choose themes like The Clairvoyants’ Convention or The Missing Will. Puzzles have 500 pieces and clues hidden inside.
It is perfect for puzzlers who love solving whodunits while assembling pieces.
8. 80s Mall Murder Madness
Set in a 1980s mall, players solve the murder of a wealthy businessman in the fountain.
Up to 20 players can participate. The game includes character sheets, clues, and a detailed storyline.
Players dress in 80s attire for a nostalgic and interactive mystery experience.
9. Murder at The Office Ugly Sweater Holiday Party
This game takes place at an office holiday party. Players wear their ugliest sweaters.
The goal is to solve the murder of a colleague. Materials include character sheets, clues, and instructions.
It is perfect for festive gatherings and office events, adding humor and suspense.
10. Murder Mystery on The Dancefloor
Set in Boogieland 77, a 70s disco club, a murder has occurred.
Up to 13 players dress in disco outfits to solve the crime using provided clues.
It offers an immersive experience for fans of both disco and mystery games.
11. Hunt A Killer: Dead Below Deck
Set on a luxurious yacht, players investigate the murder of stewardess Rachel Veinson.
Ideal for 1 to 5 players, the game includes detailed storylines, clues, props, and seafood menu ideas.
The yacht setting and music soundtrack make this game perfect for themed dinner parties.
12. Death in Antarctica
Players solve the murder of a polar station leader in this unique game.
It uses physical game pieces, emails, and a fake Instagram account for clues.
The experience is immersive and works for multiple players who enjoy innovative mysteries.
13. The Game of Thorns
A medieval-themed game where Prince Cedric is murdered. Players uncover dark secrets in the kingdom.
Designed for up to 8 players, the game includes character sheets, clues, and hosting materials.
Perfect for a medieval dinner party with intrigue and suspense.
14. The Vampire Murder Mystery
The story follows the Blackwell family, including vampires and humans.
Players investigate Count Blackwell’s death during the reading of his will. It suits 10 players and comes with detailed props.
This themed dinner party game mixes humor, horror, and mystery for an exciting evening.
15. Death is a Cabernet, Ol’ Chum
Set at Melee Vineyards, the winery owner Malcolm Melee is found dead during the anniversary event.
The game supports 8 to 50 players and includes invitations, clues, and newspaper articles.
It combines wine, cheese, and a thrilling murder mystery for a social event.
16. Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad
Players revisit a 1980s high school prom turned murder investigation.
They assume roles of high school archetypes and follow clues. The game supports large groups.
This game brings 80s nostalgia and mystery-solving fun for teens and adults alike.
17. Murder in Margaritaland
A tropical Caribbean resort is the setting where players solve a murder.
The game provides character roles, invitations, and clues. It is suitable for 8 to 30 players.
It offers a fun, colorful atmosphere with island music and themed drinks.
18. Murder on the Petulant Express
Guests solve a murder aboard a luxurious 1930s European train.
The game includes character sheets, invitations, and clues for 8 to 40 players.
It combines scenic travel and mystery-solving for an elegant party experience.
19. Murder Plays a Sour Note
Set during a New Year’s Eve jazz concert, guests solve the murder of a jazz musician.
It accommodates 8 to 80 players and includes all necessary materials.
Perfect for large parties with music, festivities, and a thrilling mystery.
20. The Disappearance of Death
A Halloween-themed game where a magician vanishes during a performance.
The kit includes character roles, clues, and instructions for 8 to 40 players.
It is ideal for spooky parties and Halloween celebrations with mystery and excitement.
